Posts tonen met het label Thomas Kuhn. Alle posts tonen
Posts tonen met het label Thomas Kuhn. Alle posts tonen

zondag 5 januari 2014

Being wrong


"Though history is unlikely to record their names, some men have undoubtedly been driven to desert science because of their inability to tolerate crisis. Like artists, creative scientists must occasionally be able to live in a world out of joint—elsewhere I have described that necessity as 'the essential tension' implicit in scientific research." (Kuhn 1962, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, pp. 78-79)

"One of the formative experiences of my Oxford undergraduate years occurred when a visiting lecturer from America presented evidence that conclusively disproved the pet theory of a deeply respected elder statesman of our zoology department, the theory that we had all been brought up on. At the end of the lecture, the old man rose, strode to the front of the hall, shook the American warmly by the hand and declared, in ringing emotional tones, 'My dear fellow, I wish to thank you. I have been wrong these fifteen years.' We clapped our hands red. Is any other profession so generous towards its admitted mistakes?" (Dawkins 1999, Unweaving the Rainbow, p. 29)

zaterdag 26 oktober 2013

Meet John Searle


"The other point that Tom [Thomas Kuhn] made, this is frequently cited, is that he says that after a scientific revolution scientists live in different worlds, that the world of Aristotle is a different world from the world of Newton. Now that is not right. I have actually been to Greece and it's not a different world. The world that Aristotle lived in—actually I've been in both countries, England and Greece—and I can tell you it is a mistake to say that they are different worlds." (Searle 1999, Rorty v. Searle, At Last: A Debate)